Key takeaways
- Gunite pools can take almost any shape and size and have a surface you can choose.
- Fiberglass pools arrive as a finished shell and install quickly, with a smooth surface.
- Vinyl liner pools are flexible in shape and have a soft surface, with a liner that is replaced from time to time.
- The right choice depends on your yard, your tastes and the upkeep you want.
Gunite and concrete
Gunite is sprayed concrete over a rebar grid. It can be any shape and any depth and can include benches, ledges, spas and vanishing edges. The interior can be plaster, pebble or quartz, with tile at the waterline. A gunite pool is strong and long-lived, though the surface wears and needs resurfacing after many years.
It takes longer to build than a fiberglass pool, because the shell has to be formed, sprayed and cured, and the finish applied.
Fiberglass
A fiberglass pool is a factory-made shell that is set into the hole with a crane. It goes in faster, the surface is smooth and non-porous and algae has a harder time clinging to it. Shapes and sizes are limited to the catalog and to what can be shipped to your yard.
It is a good fit for owners who want to swim soon and prefer less surface upkeep.
Vinyl liner
A vinyl liner pool uses a wall system and a smooth base, with a custom liner stretched over them. It is flexible in shape, soft underfoot and easy to keep clean. The liner needs to be replaced after a number of years, but that is a much smaller job than resurfacing a concrete pool.
Liners come in many patterns, so you can choose the look you like.
How to choose
Think about shape, time, surface and long-term care. If you want a custom shape and a spa, gunite fits. If you want to swim soon with a smooth surface, fiberglass fits. If you want a flexible shape and a soft surface, vinyl fits.
A good builder explains the trade-offs honestly and builds all three where it makes sense.
Official sites to explore
Brand names and logos belong to their owners. These links open the official websites in a new tab, and we are not affiliated with them.
- Pool & Hot Tub AllianceIndustry association with standards and consumer information on pools and spas.
- Pool SafelyFederal guidance on pool and spa safety for families, including barriers and drain safety.
- CDC Healthy SwimmingPublic health advice on safe, healthy swimming and pool water.
- University of Tennessee ExtensionResearch-based guidance on soils, water and home landscapes in Tennessee.
- Metro Nashville Codes DepartmentPermits and inspections for Davidson County.
Quick answers
Which pool lasts the longest?
All three can last for decades with good care, though surfaces and liners need renewing at different times.
Which type needs the least chemicals?
Smooth fiberglass resists algae well, but all pools need balanced water.
Can any pool be converted to saltwater?
Most can, and we check the surface and equipment first.




